Is it Time to Give Up the Concept of Collective Trauma? On the Need for New (Old) Lexicons to Frame Social Suffering


Resumen


¿Ha llegado el momento de prescindir del concepto de trauma colectivo? Sobre la necesidad de nuevos (viejos) léxicos para abordar el sufrimiento social


Abstract: The present paper focuses on some of the tensions that have been recurrent in the concept of psychic trauma since the late nineteenth century. It further argues that these tensions have been introduced into the concepts of collective trauma and cultural trauma, but have remained undertheorized. These theories have not been able to understand the relationship established between the structural forms of damage and its eventual forms. We therefore draw on some critiques of these concepts to point out the impasses of cultural trauma theories in understanding the dialectic between the general and the particular that is at play in socially mediated psychic suffering. We propose that in order to bring this understanding to fruition, it is necessary to look back to the tradition of critical theory and its concept of suffering, and take up its normative character through a theory of harm based on the concept of negativity.


Resumen: El presente artículo se centra en algunas de las tensiones que han sido recurrentes en el concepto de trauma psíquico desde finales del siglo xix. Además, se plantea que esas tensiones se han introducido en el concepto de trauma colectivo y de trauma cultural, pero han permanecido insuficientemente teorizadas. Estas teorías no han sido capaces de entender la relación que se establece entre las formas estructurales de daño y sus formas puntuales. Por ello, se recurre a algunas críticas de estos conceptos para señalar los impasses de las teorías del trauma cultural para comprender la dialéctica entre lo general y lo particular que está en juego en el sufrimiento psíquico socialmente mediado. Proponemos que para llevar esta comprensión a cabo, es preciso volver a mirar a la tradición de la teoría crítica y su concepto de sufrimiento, así como retomar su carácter normativo en una teoría del daño basada en el concepto de negatividad.


Keywords: Psychic Trauma, Collective Trauma, Social Suffering, Harm, Critical Theory.


Palabras clave: trauma psíquico, trauma colectivo, sufrimiento social, daño, teoría crítica.


Texto completo:

PDF (English)

Referencias


Adorno, T. W. 2014, “Revisionist Psychoanalysis”, Philosophy and Social Criticism, vol. 40 (3): 326-38.

Adorno, T. W. 2004, Negative Dialectics, London, Rotledge. 

Alexander, J. C. 2012, Trauma. A Social Theory, Cambridge, Polity Press.

Alirangues, M. 2018, “La dialéctica del olvido. Notas para reconceptualizar la tensión entre ausencia y pérdida”, Colectivo Brumaria (ed.), Olvidar/Forgetting, Madrid, Brumaria. 

American Psychiatric Association (APA) 1980, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 3ª ed. Washington, D.C., American Psychiatric Association. 

Barnaby, A. 2018, “The Psychoanalitic Origins of Literary Trauma Studies”, Kurtz, J. R. (ed.), Trauma and Literature. Cambridge University Press, 21-35.

Brown, L. S. 1995, “Not Outside the Range: One Feminist Perspective on Psychic Trauma”, Caruth, C. (ed.), Trauma: Explorations in Memory, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. 

Brown, W. 1995, States of Injury. Power and Freedom in Late Modernity, Princeton, Princeton University Press.

Caruth, C. 2016, Unclaimed Experience. Trauma, Narrative and History, 20th Anniversary Edition, Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press.

Diedrich, L. 2018, “PTSD: A New Trauma Paradigm”, Kurtz, J. R. (ed.), Trauma and Literature, Cambridge University Press, 83-94.

Erikson, K. 1976, Everything in its Path, New York, Simon and Schuster.

Haslam, N. and McGrath, M. J. 2020, “The Creeping Concept of Trauma”, Social Research: An International Quarterly, 87, 3: 509-31.

Hartmann, G. 1995, “On Traumatic Knowledge and Literary Studies”, New Literary History, 26, 3: 537-63.

Herman, J. 2015, Trauma and Recovery. The Aftermath of Violence-From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror, New York, Basic Books. 

Freud, S. and Breuer, J. 1981, “On the Psychical Mechanism of Hysterical Phenomena: Preliminary Communication”, The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud. Volume II, London, The Hogarth Press.

Kansteiner, W. and Weilnböck, H. 2008, “Against the Concept of Cultural Trauma (or How I Learned to Love the Suffering of Others without the Help pf Psychotherapy)”, Erll, A., and Nünning, A. (ed.), Cultural Memory Studies. An International and Interdisciplinary Handbook, Berlin, Walter de Gruyter, 229-40.144 

Kansteiner, W. 2004, “Genealogy of a Category Mistake: A Critical Intellectual History of the Cultural Trauma Metaphor”, Rethinking History. The Journal of Theory and Practice, 8 (2): 193-221.

Koch, U. 2021, “Between Social Criticism and Epistemological Critique: Critical Theory and the Normalization of Trauma”, Leese, P., Crouthamel, J. and Köhne, J. B., (ed.), Languages of Trauma. History, Memory, and Media, Toronto, University of Toronto Press, 213-38. 

LaCapra, D. 2014, Writing History Writing Trauma, Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press. 

Leys, R. 2000, Trauma. A Genealogy, Chicago, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago. 

Micale, M. S. and Lerner, P. 2001, “Trauma, Psychiatry, and History: A Conceptual and Historiographical Introduction”, Micale, M. S. and Lerner, P. (ed.), Traumatic Pasts. Hystory, Psychiatry and Trauma in the Modern Age, 1870-1930, Cambridge University Press. 

López, P. 2011, “Ocaso del individuo, recuerdo de lo vivo. Sujeto y naturaleza en Adorno”, Muñoz, J. (ed.), Melancolía y verdad. Invitación a la lectura de Th. W. Adorno, Madrid, Biblioteca Nueva, 33-70.

Mowitt, J. 2000, “Trauma Envy”, Cultural Critique, 46, Trauma and Its Cultural Aftereffects (Autumn, 2000): 272-97

Renault, E. 2010, “A Critical Theory of Social Suffering”, Critical Horizons. A Journal of Philosophy and Social Theory, Volume 11, Issue 2: 221-41.

Rothberg, M. 2019, The Implicated Subject. Beyond Victims and Perpetrators, Stanford, Stanford University Press. 

Rothberg, M. 2009, Multidirectional Memory: Remembering the Holocaust in the Age of Decolonization, Stanford, Stanford University Press. 

Sanfelippo, L. 2018, Trauma. Un estudio histórico en torno a Sigmund Freud, Buenos Aires, Miño y Dávila.

Sanfelippo, L. 2013, “Versiones de Trauma: LaCapra, Caruth y Freud”, Historiografías: revista de historia y teoría, 5: 51-70.

Seltzer, M. 1997, “Wound Culture: Trauma in the Pathological Public Sphere”, October, Vol. 80 (Spring): 3-26.

Smelser, N. J. 2004, “Psychological Trauma and Cultural Trauma”, Alexander, J., Eyerman, R., Giesen, B., Smelser, N. J. and Sztompka, P., Cultural Trauma and Collective Identity, Berkeley, University of California Press.

Steffens, K. 2018, “Modernity as the Cultural Crucible of Trauma”, Kurtz, J. R. (ed.), Trauma and Literature, Cambridge University Press, 21-35.

Thiebaut, C., October 2013, Harm and violence: Does the notion of harm help us to define violence and non-violence? Conference “The Many Faces of Violence”, The New School for Social Research, NY. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277345315_Harm_and_violence_Does_the_notion_of_harm_help_us_to_define_violence_and_non-violence

Young, A. 1995, The Harmony of Illusions: Inventing Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, Princeton, Princeton University Press.

Young, I. M. 2013, Responsibility for Justice, Oxford, Oxford University Press.


Enlaces refback

  • No hay ningún enlace refback.




twitter2logofecyt

 

 Licencia de Creative Commons

Esta obra está bajo una licencia de Creative Commons Reconocimiento-NoComercial-SinObraDerivada 4.0 Internacional.